Turns Leave Fingerprints

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Hi Traders,

A mentor of mine used to say, “One stock does not a market make.”

So why did one headline about one company move $400 billion? Because that’s how a market acts near a turn, and I want to show you how to spot one.

Nobody rings a bell at the top, but turns usually leave the same fingerprints.

I learned that on the AMEX floor. When a theme ran on the news all day and everybody I talked to had it on, that fever pitch usually hit right around when the thing rolled over.

This week I went back and read what the greats wrote about it, and they saw the same thing. Humphrey Neill wrote it down in 1954: “When everyone thinks alike, everyone is likely to be wrong.”

Once everybody’s made the trade, there’s nobody left to make it.

Four of these fingerprints show up over and over, and you can watch for them in anything you trade.


Institutions Leave Fingerprints in the Options Chain

Andrew Giovinazzi built an AI scanner to track them. It flagged Chewy at $23 before the stock ran to $112.

See What It’s Flagging Now


1. Everybody’s in, and it’s narrow. Right now the trade is long the AI buildout and short bonds, and it’s worked all summer. Hans Albrecht pointed out on the show that 10 stocks have done 70 percent of the lifting since March 30, and breadth (how many stocks join the move) is as bad as it’s been in 25 years. Bob Farrell at Merrill Lynch had a rule for this: markets are strongest when they’re broad and weakest when they narrow to a handful of names.

2. The market gets jumpy. When everybody’s in the same trade, everybody’s got a finger on the sell button, so small news causes big moves. If one headline can knock $400 billion off the Nasdaq, think about what a real catalyst could do.

3. Things stop working the way they used to. All summer, when oil went up, bonds went down. Thursday oil jumped five bucks and bonds rallied anyway. When a relationship that’s worked every day suddenly breaks, that’s a really big heads up.

George Soros called this the twilight period, when doubts grow and people lose faith but the trend keeps rolling on inertia.

4. The buyers disappear. At the top of a hot theme, everybody who owns it wants to sell it to you, and eventually nobody’s left to buy. This week an AI data center company pulled a $30 billion IPO because it couldn’t find buyers. Thirteen of the 17 AI companies that went public this year trade below their IPO price, and in 2000 that was the sign.

Seeing the fingerprints doesn’t mean you call the top. The AI buildout is real, and big expansions need a pause so reality can catch up with the hype. The greats never traded the signs alone, either.

Stan Druckenmiller said he never used valuation to time a turn. He watched liquidity and the charts for timing, and he waited for a catalyst to change the direction.

When I see the fingerprints, I stick to four rules:

  1. Don’t fight the trend just because it’s crowded. Fading new highs (betting against a stock at its highs) and buying falling knives is how people get run over.
  2. Wait for the pause, then the catalyst. The trend has to stall first.
  3. Define your loss before you get in, and size it like you might be early. Being right about the turn doesn’t help if you get carried out waiting for it.
  4. Don’t add to a loser unless adding was the plan. I’ve watched too many people blow out that way.

I’m seeing these fingerprints right now, and that’s my cue to figure out what the catalyst might look like before it gets here. CPI (the government’s monthly inflation report) comes out Wednesday, and everybody expects it hot. When the whole crowd leans one way into a number, watch what happens if it comes in the other way.

Enjoy the journey,

Tim

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Tim Colby is a macro trader and strategist with 15 years of derivatives experience spanning the AMEX and CBOE trading floors through managing a discretionary macro portfolio. He built strategies that scaled past $200M in AUM, delivered 75% profitable months with no losing years, and earned a Pinnacle Award nomination for best three-year discretionary return.

Share This Article

Tim Colby

Reboot

The Dollar-Store Masking Tape Holding This Market Up

By Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Reboot

I Read the News Second

By Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Reboot

The Junkiest Bonds Just Crossed a Line

By Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Pit Report

Credit’s Cracking. Why Are Chips Still Up?

By Tim Colby

About the Author

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Former CBOE floor trader and CIO at Karman Line Capital. Author of ‘The Option Traders Hedge Fund’ with over 30 years of options trading experience.

Popular Posts

Categories

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter for daily trading insights

Upcoming Events

FOMC Meeting

2:00 PM EST

Earnings Season Begins

Pre-market

Options Expiration

Market Close

NFP Report

8:30 AM EST