Where Does Money Hide When Bonds Are Burning

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Hi Traders.

Three of my risk charts have spent this year out of step with each other. The short answer is oil. The long answer changes what "safe" even means.

During this spring's oil shock, as fear worked into the market, bonds didn't rally. They got sold.

Part one was why the yen, the VIX and the 30-year bond normally spike together.

Part two was two governments defusing a bomb while the VIX slept through it.

This one is about the gauge that stopped doing its job.

The Bond's Old Job

For basically forever, the 30-year bond had one job. It was the place money ran to when it got scared.

Some scary event pops up that looks like it will slow the economy down. Managers sell stocks and buy bonds. The bigger and longer the slowdown looks, the further out they go, all the way to the 30-year.

And it's a beautiful trade. You dodge the stock drawdown and you make money on the way out, because the thing you're scared of is slower growth, and slower growth is exactly what makes bonds rally.

That's the pattern every risk model on Wall Street learned. Stocks down, bonds up. It held from 2000 straight through 2020, and a whole generation of managers never traded any other way.

Then 2022 broke it. Russia invaded Ukraine, oil spiked, inflation showed up, the Fed jacked up interest rates, and stocks and bonds went down together. It was the first year since 1972 that both stocks and long Treasuries lost money.

Everyone called it a fluke. Then it happened again.

Go back to February. On the 27th, the day before the Iran war started, the 30-year yielded 4.61 percent and the 10-year sat at 3.94 percent. The war opened the next morning and managers sold Treasuries instead of buying them.

By May 19 the 30-year touched 5.19 percent, the highest since 2007. Yields up means bond prices down, so read that as a bond market getting dumped into a war. The scared-money trade ran backwards.

Every Hiding Spot Has a Guess Built Into It

Watch what actually happens during a scare and you learn two things. Whatever's getting dumped shows you the center of the problem. Whatever's rallying shows you where people are running.

When those two move in lockstep on headlines during the event, they show you exactly where the money is flowing. That's the whole reason I keep these charts.

Every one of those safety assets has an assumption built in. A hiding spot only works if the trouble comes from somewhere else.

Bonds are a great place to hide if the scare is about growth slowing down. Slow growth means interest rates eventually come down, and bonds love that.

The yen is a different animal. When it spikes, nobody is hiding in Japan. The yen is the loan underneath everyone else's positions, borrowed cheap to buy things everywhere else, so a spike means somebody is being marched out of a trade and has to pay that loan back on the way out the door.

Line up the last few years and the pattern is plain.

The growth scare, 2000 to 2020: stocks down, bonds up, gold up, yen up. Every hiding spot does its job. It's the world every model was trained on.

The energy inflation scare, 2022 and again this year: stocks down, bonds down, gold down, dollar up. Almost nothing hedged. The one group that worked was energy, up roughly 34 percent this year against about nine percent for the S&P 500, which tells you the best hedge was owning the problem itself. That and plain cash.

The dollar scare, spring 2025 and again this January: stocks down, bonds down, gold up, dollar down. After the April 2025 tariff announcement the S&P fell about 12 percent, the dollar lost about six percent, and long-end yields climbed. Moody's pulled the country's last AAA rating a month later. Gold was the one thing that worked.

There's no single hiding spot for every storm. Each one works in its own weather.

In 2026 the shock was oil, and oil bled straight into the price of money. Expensive oil means hotter inflation, hotter inflation means interest rates go up instead of down, and every one of those hiding spots is priced off interest rates.

That's why my gauges stopped agreeing. It was one problem showing up on three screens.

When the Hiding Spot Is the Fire

Bonds haven't been the place money runs to lately. Rising yields are the thing money is running from.

The bond didn't stop being a risk gauge. It switched sides, from measuring where money hides to being the thing everyone's afraid of.

And it isn't just oil keeping that fire lit. The AI build-out needs staggering amounts of capital, and the companies putting up the data centers have started borrowing it.

The five biggest tech names averaged about $28 billion a year in bond sales from 2020 through 2024. They did $121 billion in 2025. They did $159 billion in the first five months of this year alone.

Buyers are starting to push back. Orders for those bonds covered nearly five times the amount offered in February. By July, coverage had slipped under two times.

That doesn't break anything. It means the borrowers pay up, and it's one more weight sitting on the long end of the curve.

Which leaves the question I keep turning over. When money gets scared of its own hiding place, where does it go?

The Way Back for Bonds

Here's the good news, and it's a real answer to that question.

Before the war, everybody knew oil was heading lower. U.S. production is running at a record 13.8 million barrels a day. The Energy Information Administration's pre-war forecast had Brent averaging $58 a barrel this year.

The same agency now has Brent near $85 for this quarter, falling to an average of $69 next year as Hormuz traffic normalizes. So we don't need oil back at $60. We just need the headwind holding it above $80 to lift.

When the market believes the conflict is really ending, the whole risk machine runs in reverse. Inflation fear drains out, interest rates come down, and bonds have a long way to rally.

The politics are the watch point. The President would love cheap oil going into the midterms. Iran would love to deny him exactly that.

I have no idea which of them gets his way or when, and I don't need to. We don't bet on the timing. We know the weight is sitting on the market, and we know which direction things move when it lifts.

One last thought. Having risk gauges isn't the hard part. Anyone can run the numbers on what moves with what and put charts on a screen.

The hard part is knowing what each one assumes, because the day the world stops matching the assumption, your fire alarm goes quiet at exactly the wrong moment.

How I build that wall of gauges, which ones I watch, and how I know when to retire one: that's the next piece.

Enjoy the process,

Tim

 

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Tim Colby is a macro trader and strategist with 15 years of derivatives experience spanning the AMEX and CBOE trading floors through managing a discretionary macro portfolio. He built strategies that scaled past $200M in AUM, delivered 75% profitable months with no losing years, and earned a Pinnacle Award nomination for best three-year discretionary return.

Share This Article

About the Author

Tim Colby

Tim Colby

Former CBOE floor trader and CIO at Karman Line Capital. Author of ‘The Option Traders Hedge Fund’ with over 30 years of options trading experience.

Popular Posts

Categories

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter for daily trading insights

Upcoming Events

FOMC Meeting

2:00 PM EST

Earnings Season Begins

Pre-market

Options Expiration

Market Close

NFP Report

8:30 AM EST