Why the Average Stock Is Beating the Index

Dear Trader,

On Thursday at the lows, the S&P 500 sat down 80 points. By the close, it had clawed back half that loss, finishing down just 40 points at 6,908. But the real story isn't in the cap-weighted index. It's in what the average stock is doing.

Take a look at RSP, the equal-weight S&P 500 ETF. It closed near all-time highs. That tells you everything you need to know about what's actually happening in this market.

This is a correction, but not the kind you're used to.

NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA) reported earnings Wednesday night and they crushed it. Revenue surged 73 percent to $68.1 billion, beating Wall Street's $65.9 billion estimate. Earnings came in at $1.62 per share versus expectations of $1.53. Guidance blew past forecasts too, with management calling for $78 billion in first-quarter sales against the $72.8 billion consensus.

And the stock dropped 5.5 percent anyway, marking its worst day since April.

Why PE Tells the Real Story

The answer isn't complicated. Two years ago, when AI was just becoming a thing, NVDA's PE ratio topped 70. Today it sits around 46. According to FinanceCharts data, the five-year average PE for the stock is over 70, so the current multiple represents significant compression.

That number will eventually land in the high 20s or low 30s. NVDA had a historic run until November 2024. Since then, the stock has essentially gone sideways. TradingView analysis confirms the stock has spent the past six months consolidating rather than making new highs.

This is what a "time correction" looks like. The earnings aren't disappointing. They're growing into a valuation that already priced in incredible results. The reward for NVDA is becoming the most valuable company in the world. But the multiple had to compress first.

The Great Rotation Is Here

Meanwhile, the rest of the market is waking up. Market breadth has reached its healthiest levels in over three years, with 65.8 percent of the S&P 500 now trading above their 200-day moving averages.

The Magnificent Seven dominated returns for years. At one point, the top ten stocks accounted for over 40 percent of the S&P 500's total weight. That concentration historically precedes either a correction or a rotation.

We got the rotation.

Money is flowing out of mega-cap tech and into the "other 493" stocks. Domestic manufacturing, regional banking, industrials. The Russell 2000 has surged nearly eight percent in the first five weeks of 2026 while the Nasdaq 100 limped along with a 1.5 percent gain.

What I'm Doing Now

Looking ahead to today, PPI matters, but not like other data releases. Tuesday and Wednesday were a market-wide short squeeze because no one wanted to be short heading into NVDA earnings. That squeeze is over.

Based on what I'm seeing in bonds and VIX, I think we're heading for a rough Friday and Monday before forming a constructive bottom.

Here's my positioning:

Buying: Reddit (RDDT), Microsoft (MSFT), IBM (IBM), energy, Amazon (AMZN), banks.

Selling: Apple (AAPL), Target (TGT), non-Microsoft software, private credit lenders, crypto companies including MicroStrategy (MSTR).

Today I expect the market to be soft.

I'll look for chances to press it lower. We're finally set up for that capitulation moment. It might take a few days, but it's coming. And when it arrives, it'll be a generational long opportunity.

Your only option,

Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian is a former member of both the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) and the American Stock Exchange (AMEX), where he spent years mastering the art of options trading in the most competitive environment imaginable. As Chief Investment Officer at the hedge fund Karman Line Capital, Mark manages sophisticated options strategies for institutional clients. He is the author of two highly regarded books on options trading: ‘The Option Traders Hedge Fund’ and ‘Trading Options for Edge.’ Mark is a frequent guest on major financial networks including CNBC, Fox Business News, Bloomberg, and First Business News, where he provides expert commentary on market volatility and options strategies.

Share This Article

Mark Sebastian

Insider's Edge

My Fear Gauge Is A Single Stock

By Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

State of the Market

Jackson Hole Was Never About Rates

By Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

Trader's Edge

I Was the Kid in the Chevy Commercial

By Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

Pit Report

Ford just became an AI stock

By Mark Sebastian

About the Author

Mark Sebastian

Mark Sebastian

Former CBOE floor trader and CIO at Karman Line Capital. Author of ‘The Option Traders Hedge Fund’ with over 30 years of options trading experience.

Popular Posts

Categories

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter for daily trading insights

Upcoming Events

FOMC Meeting

2:00 PM EST

Earnings Season Begins

Pre-market

Options Expiration

Market Close

NFP Report

8:30 AM EST